Advocacy Skills in Cases Involving Persons
with Mental Disabilities: The Role of Lawyers and Expert
Witnesses
The goal of this course is to teach students the
special advocacy skills needed by lawyers and expert witnesses that are
essential in cases involving persons with mental disabilities. The course
will cover topics including civil commitment standards; outpatient
commitment; issues of proof; dealing with expert witnesses; rights to
community services; forensic issues; patient advocacy issues; and dealing
with stigma/public awareness. This course includes two recorded simulated
trials, one of an involuntary civil commitment case, and one of an
incompetency to stand trial hearing. For JD students the prerequisite is
Survey of Mental Disability Law or an advanced degree, training, or
professional experience in any aspect of psychology, psychiatry, social
work, or other allied therapeutic field. In certain very limited other
circumstances, JD students will be allowed to enroll by permission of
Prof. Michael Perlin, Director, Online Mental Disability Law Program. For
master’s degree and certificate students, Survey of Mental
Disability Law is a pre-requisite or co-requisite.
The Americans with Disabilities Act: Law, Policy and Practice
Explores legal, policy, and practical implications of the
Americans with Disabilities Act as it applies to people with both physical
and mental disabilities (with a significant focus on issues involving
mental disability). The course will cover the wide range of
disability-based discrimination that the ADA addresses, including
questions of discrimination, access to services, access to the judicial
system, institutional rights, and community rights. Students will study
the contextualization of the ADA and mental disability law jurisprudence;
definitions of "disability"; issues involving employment
discrimination; discrimination in public accommodations and professional
licensing; housing discrimination; discrimination in public services;
institutional segregation as discrimination; the ADA and the criminal
justice system; and sovereign immunity and access to courts. For
master’s degree and certificate students, Survey of Mental
Disability Law is a pre-requisite or co-requisite.
Custody Evaluations, Juvenile and Family Law, and Mental
Disabilities
This course will consider the full range of
issues related to custody (including issues specifically related to
children with special needs), adoption, marriage dissolution, foster care,
domestic abuse and guardianships as they relate to persons with mental
disabilities. Students will examine the special issues related to juvenile
commitments to psychiatric institutions (and treatment of juveniles in such
facilities); competency; as well as other issues related to the criminal
trials of juveniles with mental disabilities. This course will furthermore
focus on the role of problem-solving courts, and the application of
international human rights principles to this area of the law. For
master’s degree and certificate students, Survey of Mental
Disability Law is a pre-requisite or co-requisite. For JD students, family
law is highly recommended as a pre-requisite or co-requisite.
Forensic Reports, the Role of Experts, and Forensic
Ethics
This course will deal with both the reports that are
prepared by forensic experts for use by lawyers (both pre-trial and at
trial), and with the ethical issues that are posed when such experts
interact with the legal system. The focus will be on the full range of
issues involving forensic experts and the mental disability law system:
the rights of persons subject to institutionalization and who have been
institutionalized, and the role of mental disability in the criminal trial
process, in the civil trial process, in the criminal trial process, and in
the family law process. Therapeutic jurisprudence implications will be
also be explored, as will a consideration of the varying ethical codes
that apply to the different mental health professions. For JD students,
the pre-requisite is Survey of Mental Disability Law or Advocacy Skills in
Cases Involving Persons with Mental Disability Law: the Role of Lawyers and
Expert Witnesses or permission of Prof. Michael Perlin, Director, Online
Mental Disability Law Program. For master’s degree and certificate
students, Survey of Mental Disability Law is a pre-requisite or
co-requisite.
International Human Rights and
Mental Disability Law
This course will examine the
relationship between constitutional mental disability law and
international human rights law, primarily as that relationship deals with
questions of legislative drafting, legal representation, institutional
treatment, community care, and forensic mental health systems. It will
cover a comparison of civil and common law systems, an overview of
international human rights law, an overview of regional human rights
tribunals, an overview of US constitutional mental disability law, the
role of "sanism" and "pretextuality" in understanding
developments in this area, mental disability law in an international human
rights context, comparative mental disability law, the use of institutional
psychiatry as a means of suppressing political dissension, the
"universal factors" in this area of law, and the globalization
of disability law. The focus will be on both American law and on
international human rights norms (e.g., the UN Convention on the Rights of
Persons with Disabilities), the developing body of case law in the
Inter-American, European and African Courts and Commissions on Human
Rights, and the absence of a regional tribunal to enforce disability
rights in Asia. For master’s degree and certificate students, Survey
of Mental Disability Law is a pre-requisite or co-requisite.
Mental Disability and Criminal Law
This course
will explore in depth the relationship between mental disability and the
criminal trial process. Topics to be discussed will include all aspects of
the criminal incompetency status (including trial, plea, counsel waiver and
other pre-trial, trial and post-trial stages); the insanity defense;
institutionalization and release policies that govern the cases of persons
found permanently incompetent to stand trial and those found not guilty by
reason of insanity; the right of forensic patients to refuse antipsychotic
medications; the role of mental disability evidence in other aspects of
criminal trial and pre-trial proceedings (including confessions and
privilege against self-incrimination matters); sentencing, the death
penalty (including issues involving mitigation, predictions of future
dangerousness, executability of persons with mental retardation, and
competency to be executed); and questions as to the effectiveness of
counsel in cases involving mentally disabled defendants. Class videos will
include a simulated trial of a case involving a criminal defendant with a
mental disability. For master’s degree and certificate students,
Survey of Mental Disability Law is a pre-requisite or
co-requisite.
Mental Health Issues in Jails and
Prisons
This course offers a comprehensive overview of the
mental disability law issues in correctional settings (jails &
prisons). Topics include the historical development of the constitutional
right to correctional health and mental health care, issues involving
staffing, transfer, record keeping, suicide prevention, the significance
of professional standards, the relationship between correctional mental
health care and community systems of care, monitoring, informed consent,
risk assessment, and privatization of services. For master’s degree
and certificate students, Survey of Mental Disability Law is a
pre-requisite or co-requisite.
Mental Illness,
Dangerousness, the Police Power and Risk Assessment
This
course will deal with the relationship between mental illness, dangerous
behavior and the police power, the ability of mental health professionals
to predict dangerousness, and the significance of risk assessment
instruments for a variety of decisions to be made in the legal system.
Students will discover how these relationships and concepts play
out” in a variety of settings, including involuntary civil
commitments, right to refuse treatment, insanity defense acquittee
retention hearings, sex offender status hearings, sentencing cases, death
penalty “future dangerousness” inquiries, death penalty
mitigation hearings, and Tarasoff (duty to protect) cases in civil law.
For master’s degree and certificate students, Survey of Mental
Disability Law is a pre-requisite or co-requisite. For JD students, the
pre-requisite is Survey of Mental Disability Law or Advocacy Skills in
Cases Involving Persons with Mental Disabilities: the Role of Lawyers and
Expert Witnesses or Sex Offenders, or an advanced degree, training, or
professional experience in any aspect of psychology, psychiatry, social
work, or other allied therapeutic field. In certain very limited other
circumstances, students will be allowed to enroll by permission of Prof.
Michael Perlin, Director, Online Mental Disability Law Program.
Race, Gender, Class, and Mental
Disability
Individuals with mental disabilities have
traditionally been and continue to be subjected to rights violations and
pervasive discrimination because of their mental disabilities. For
individuals who are racial minorities and/or are women, and/or without
economic means, and/or not from the dominant culture, the struggles to
overcome these rights violations and discrimination are even greater
precisely because of their race and/or gender and/or social class and/or
culture. The confluence of mental disability, gender, race, culture, and
class often result in unique legal issues that have a far reaching impact
on virtually every aspect of their lives.
This course will focus on the unique legal issues that these individuals face because of these relationships. Specifically, students will examine the impact of the interrelationship of these factors, both in the context of American and international law, on a full array of legal issues affecting this population, such as: civil commitment; institutional rights; access to counsel; forensic mental health topics including: incompetency to stand trial, the insanity and other related defenses, sentencing, and related issues, and the death penalty; domestic violence; abuse and neglect; trafficking of women with mental disabilities for slavery; individual rights and personal autonomy including sterilization, the right to engage in consensual sexual interaction, the right to marry, the right to have and raise children; barriers to the availability of community-based benefits and supports and services, including mental health and general medical care; and access to public accommodations. Furthermore, students will consider all these issues in the context of problem-solving courts. For master’s degree and certificate students, Survey of Mental Disability Law is a pre-requisite or co-requisite.
Sex Offenders
This
course will review contemporary public policy regarding sexually coercive
behavior. A major focus will be the aggressive legislative approaches to
sexual violence developed in the United States over the past 15 years. We
will examine and evaluate these controversial legal approaches, as well as
alternative approaches to the societal effort to address sexual violence.
The course will include an examination of the current state of social
science research into sexual violence, including etiology, classification,
treatment, supervision, recidivism, and risk assessment. Our examination of
legislative approaches to sexual violence will seek an understanding of the
operation of these laws, the constitutional litigation challenging them,
the legal issues currently in controversy, and an attempt to assess their
efficacy as part of a system for addressing sexual violence in society.
The course will address issues at a variety of levels of abstraction,
examining the morality of the laws, their implications for public policy
and the fight against sexual violence, as well as the practical skills and
knowledge necessary for lawyers and other professionals to operate
effectively. For master’s degree and certificate students, Survey of
Mental Disability Law is a pre-requisite or
co-requisite.
Survey of Mental Disability
Law
This course is the gateway to all mental disability law
courses as it provides a comprehensive look at many of the issues that
will be considered at greater length in the more specialized classes, and
provides the basic doctrines fundamental to the understanding of mental
disability law. Students will examine the civil and constitutional bases
of mental disability law in such areas as civil commitment; institutional
rights (with specific focus on the right to refuse treatment); and
deinstitutionalization, aftercare, and federal statutory rights (with
specific focus on the Americans with Disabilities Act). Students will
explore the role of mental disability in the criminal trial process,
including criminal incompetencies; insanity defense; sexually violent
predator laws; federal sentencing guidelines; and the death penalty.
Students will also study the history of mental disability law and why and
how it has developed as it has; and most importantly, why judges and fact
finders decide mental disability law cases the way they do, to facilitate
our predictions of future trends and outcomes. For master’s degree
and certificate students, this is a core requirement which must be taken
in the first semester However, if a student is beginning the program in
the spring semester, then this course must be taken in either the
immediate subsequent summer or fall semesters.
Therapeutic Jurisprudence
Students explore the
proposition that all aspects of the legal system (and all roles played by
judicial actors) have some therapeutic impact on mentally disabled
individuals who are litigants or are the subject of litigation. The course
focuses on the empirical issues and social assumptions underlying the major
mental disability legal doctrines developed in the past three decades in
such areas as involuntary civil commitment law, rights of persons
institutionalized because of disability, correctional law, the criminal
trial process, legal education, and international human rights law. For
master’s degree and certificate students, Survey of Mental
Disability Law is a pre-requisite or co-requisite.
Trauma and Mental Disability
The class covers
several primary themes of interest to legal practitioners, mental health
clinicians, and disability advocates. These include: the treatment of
trauma-related disabilities in civil and criminal courts, the role of
trauma in the legal treatment of people with mental disabilities, and the
relationship between trauma and disability subordination. The course also
entails review of the possible policy, legal, and therapeutic points of
intervention, geared towards shifting the relationship between law,
trauma, and people with mental disabilities. Issues will be examined
through a legal, legislative and policy lens.
Some
issues explored include the following: how issues involving trauma induced
mental disabilities, such as PTSD, among others, are dealt with in both
civil and criminal courts; a special focus on children, who experience
domestic violence and abuse in foster care or in juvenile detention which
results in trauma induced mental disability and how this arises in this
context related to eligibility of children in special education under the
Individuals with Disabilities Education Act or for school accommodations
for these disabilities under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act; trauma
induced mental disabilities related to veterans who return from the Iraq
war with PTSD and end up in the criminal justice system or have civil
issues relating to their disability such as employment discrimination,
access to mental health treatment and services; issues related to women
with trauma induced mental disabilities as a result of rape, abuse,
trafficking, war and as refugees and prisoners/inmates both in the civil
and criminal context. Furthermore, the course will probe unique legal
issues presented by stigma and trauma induced disabilities and how
applying the concepts of therapeutic jurisprudence can be used to address
and hopefully reduce stigma. For master’s degree and certificate
students, Survey of Mental Disability Law is a pre-requisite or
co-requisite.