New York Law School Home
Home » Beth Noveck » Innovation Law Spring 2006

Innovation Law Syllabus, Spring 2006
Professors Murphy and Noveck
T, TR - 6:00-7:15 pm, B400

Week 1 - Introduction to Innovation and the Law

Tuesday, January 17: Introduction - What Is Innovation?

Law: Copyright Basics

Thursday, January 19: Original Work of Authorship? The Internet and Challenges to the Notion of Originality and Authorship (Murphy)

Law Case Study: Copyrighting Code
Technology Case Study: Source and Object Code

Week 2 - The Rights of Copyright

Tuesday, January 24: Music Copyright Refresher (Murphy)

Thursday, January 26: Rights of Copyright Owners: Right of Reproduction (Murphy)

Law: Right to Copy

17 USC 106

Arnstein v. Porter, 154 F.2d 454 (2d Cir. 1946) (infringing the right to copy) (review)

Positive Black Talk v. Cash Money Records (5th Cir. 2005)

Bridgeport Music, Inc. v Dimension Films, 383 F.3d 390 (6th Cir. 2003)

Newton v. Diamond , 388 F.3d 1189 (9th Cir. 2004)

Technology Case Study: Pianola Rolls and Copyright Law's Response (Browse Online)

History of the Pianola

Browse web resources

White-Smith Music Co. v. Apollo Co., 209 U.S. 1 (1908)



Week 3 - Idea v. Expression

Tuesday, January 31: When is a Copy Not a Copy?

Law and Technology Case Study: Google Print

Thursday, February 2: Databases (Noveck)

17 USC 105 , 17 USC 201

Feist Publications v. Rural Telephone, 499 U.S. 340 (1991) (excerpt)

Assessment Technologies v. WireData, 350 F.3d 640, 2003 WL 22783823, 7th Cir.(Wis.) (Nov 25, 2003)

Consumer Access to information Act of 2004 (HR3872)

Database and Collections of Information Misappropriations Act of 2003 (H.R. 3261)

EU Database Directive 96/9/EC

Copyright Office Report on the Legal Protection of Databases (1997, pps. 1-15)


Week 4 - Rights of Distribution, First Sale Doctrine and Right to Prepare Derivative Works

Tuesday, February 7: Right of Distribution and the First Sale Doctrine (Noveck)

17 USC 109

R. Anthony Reese, The First Sale Doctrine in the Era of Digital Networks

See www.sharedevil.com

Thursday, February 9: Right to Prepare Derivative Works - Machinima and the Future of Film (Noveck)

Law:

17 USC 102, 17 USC 103

Paul Goldstein, Copyright's Highway, Chapter 3 and 4

Technology Case Study: Machinima (read online)

Machinima.org (Browse)

Red versus Blue (Browse)

Fiona Ng, Thinking Outside the Xbox for Films, LA Times, January 3, 2004

Brad King, Machinima: Games Act Like Films, July 23, 2002, Wired

Leander Kahney, Games Invade Hollywood's Turf, Wired, July 9, 2003

FAQ on Machinima: What is Machinima?

Lights, Camera, and Machinima


Week 5 - Rights of Performance - The Future of Music

Tuesday, February 14: Digital Music (Murphy)

Law:

Audio Home Recording Act , 17 USC Chp.10 and 17 USC 115

Recording Industry Association v. Diamond Multimedia, 180 F.3d 1072 (9th Cir. 1999)

UMG v. MP3.com (S.D.N.Y. 2000)

William Coats, Heather Rafter, Vickie Feeman, John Given, Streaming into the Future: Music and Video Online, Loyola of Los Angeles Entertainment Law Journal, volume 20, pp. 285-307. (skim)


Technology:

Satellite Radio (XM and Sirius); iTunes


Music Copyright and the Challenge of P2P

Thursday, February 16 (Murphy)

Law:

Fred Von Lohmann, P2P Whitepaper: P2P File Sharing and Copyright Law After Napster (Electronic Frontier Foundation) (browse)

Clay Shirky Writings on P2P (browse online)

MGM v. Grokster, __ U.S. __ (2005)

William W. Fisher, Promises to Keep: Technology, Law and the Future of Entertainment, Chapter 6 (Pages 1-4); Development of an Alternate Compensation System for Digital Media in a Global Environment; William Fisher, A Royalties Plan for File Sharing, CNet (July 11, 2003)


Week 6

Tuesday, February 21: No Tuesday classes - Monday classes meet


New Rights of Copyright Holders: ParaCopyright and Intermediaries

Thursday, February 23: Digital Millennium Copyright Act (Subpoena Power) (Noveck)

DMCA Summary from U.S. Copyright Office


Week 8 - New Rights of Copyright Holders: The Right to Use

Tuesday, February 28 Digital Millennium Copyright Act (Anti-Circumvention) (Murphy)

Law
Technology Case Study: DVD

Thursday, March 2 (Mike Godwin, EFF)

Law
Technology Case Study: Digital Rights Management & E-Books (browse)


March 7 & March 9: No Classes, Spring Break


Week 9 - Licensing and Contracts for Copyrights

Tuesday, March 14: Linux and Open Source Computing - What is Open Source?

Thursday, March 16: Why Open Source

Friday, March 17: Open Source Licensing - IBM Lecture - 9-12 (optional)


Week 10

Tuesday, March 21: Faculty Presentation Day, Special Class Meeting Time - 7:30-8:15

Special, shortened class meeting after the last panel 7:30-8:15

Creative Commons License (some rights reserved) - browse website thoroughly and make sure to create your own license

Thursday, March 23: Art and the Net (Brian Murphy)


Week 11

Tuesday, March 28: Net and Art Cont'd, Character and Copyright

Thursday, March 30: MMPORGs, Videogames and Copyright

Law:
Technology Case Study: Game Emulators & Game Mods

Week 12

Tuesday, April 4: Digital Property/Virtual Property

Thursday, April 6: Joint Works and Collaborative Creativity

Week 13 Google Law

Tuesday, April 11:

Thursday, April 13: Passover, No Class


Week 14 - Defenses to Copyright Infringement

Tuesday, April 18:

Law
Technology Case Study: Digital Video Recorders

Tuesday, April 20:

Law


Week 15

Tuesday, April 25

  • New copyright/Net cases

Thursday, April 27

  • Review and Recap